Everybody Knows This is Nowhere – ALA 2000
(With apologies to Neil Young

Association Central ad First off I would be remiss if I did not extend a grateful thanks to Deb Robertson and her staff in the ALA Press Office for all the help they were to me. When I needed something they either found it for me or knew who could. These folks do not get a lot of recognition, but as far as I am concerned, they made my life at this very large and unwieldy show much more comfortable. WLN at ALA Hi-lites
Best of Show
MarcMagician
ALUG Reunion
ALUG Photos

Best of Show

How Stupid Is This?
It has been our tradition to recognize, in our humble opinion, the "Best of Show" but it is important to remind our readers that I am only interested in technology. My methodology isn’t necessarily graduate school either, I go through the program and wander the hall and if it jumps out and bites me then we look at it. Brief (bikini?) Bits
Even More Stupid
Old Friends
For 2000 it’s a toss up between MarcMagician from Hank Epstein and MitinetMarc and Norman Kline’s LIBRARYCOM from CASPR. Actually these are variations on old standbys, and come from folks who I have known and trusted for years. Joke of the Show
Special Thanks To

Hank EpsteinMarcMagician is a MARC data cleanup and maintenance tool that could have saved my hind end innumerable times in the past. It automatically repairs MARC records, provides for global editing, and has active error checking unmatched by anything I have seen. I can’t believe anyone who works with MARC records wouldn’t want this in their software arsenal, and at $499 it could pay for itself in a week.

Hank has been massaging records longer than I have had keyboards. MitinetMarc still is a standout for original record creation, and the magician fills out the product line nicely.

Notes on the Journey
Other Stuff of Interest

Norman KlineLIBRARYCOM has slipped my radar screen (perhaps because I had it turned off?) and what Norman has created is a free library automation system. That’s right, free for the first seat and only $50 per seat for additional users. It’s been around for a year and somehow I missed it…Maybe I need to go to this show a little more often.

It’s a full fledged puppy with a decent online web catalog, circulation functions (including printing overdues and notices) and allows you to create union catalog by joining together the holdings of several libraries.

Where this product seems really important to me is all of the very little libraries, especially local history and genealogy collections that lack the funds to automate. They might have to spend some time with a tool like MitinetMarc or anything else that would allow you to create MARC records, but you cant beat the price and functionality.

TOP

Other Stuff of Interest

Web Shackles

In some circles, this is also known as "filtering" and there were several variations on this theme at the show. Schools have to struggle with this a lot more than public libraries, and it all boils down to can Johnny go to Whitehouse.com (I didn’t bother with a link for obvious reasons) from his school computer?

We are evolving from filters, which act like bots and nuke sites by language criteria. In Ohio, a lot of folks expended a great deal of time and effort on the Library Channel (which to my understanding is now toast) and invested a huge number of staff hours identifying and capturing links.

The next generation is a service – with a review policy and trained folks picking sites and organizing them.

inetlibrary

Of the ones I viewed at the show the best, in my humble opinion, was inetlibrary. Here’s the info from their front screen:

Today you get 218,427 searchable, categorized, and safe Internet sites. Site Map

Every site has been reviewed for quality, graded, and cross referenced with the National Standards in Education.

No filter was used, every site has been reviewed by professional educators under the direction of Dr. Dennis Jensen. Review Policy

At no additional cost, you get Ask the Expert. Professionals such as a School Attorney, School Administrator, several Authors, Professional Educators in different fields, and a teen/preteen Guidance Specialist respond to your questions with their opinions.

You have the world's largest collection of personally selected sites. Taller than the Empire State Building.

We are the experts at reviewing, grading, sorting and selecting relevant educational sites for teachers and students.

I got to spend some time with Dr. Jenson, and he gets the Wired Librarian’s Seal of Approval. The review policy seems sensible, and the large number of reviewed sites indicates to me they didn’t start this project in time to get the site up for the show.

In playing with the site back here at the ML World headquarters, I submitted an "Ask an Expert" question, another neat feature of the site. We’ll see how long it takes to get a response. I was a little concerned that there weren’t a ton of questions posted (it works like a FAQ file)

There are some neat categories already built for quick access such as College Section, Country Resources, Current Events, Educational, Home Section, Kids Zone, Legal Center, Lesson Plans, Media Center, Reference Section, Religion, School Search, State Resources, Subject Areas, Teen Zone . Minimally surfing through them they are well done, though far from robust. For example, in the "Ohio General Information" section neither OPLIN nor the State Library are listed, both containing excellent resources. I sent them a request to add it in the "Add a Site" feature and we’ll just have to wait and see.

inetlibrary can be configured by IP, and they have a neat feature that provides for home access. The "Plus" feature is where the library can control the shackles. They include twenty-seven different categories from "hate speech" to "games and fun" with five options for customizing your blocking strategy. Reviewed sites from the categories are in the database, but when someone surfs from within the shell

Pricing is based on enrollment, and a school district with 499 students gets hit for $999 for the package, $11,99 for the plus version. They also provide "School and Home Access" at $4.75 each. If you just want to purchase home access its $49.79 per year. Looks like a rounding thing from an Excel spreadsheet to me,,,

Tutor.com

Their motto is "teach what you know – learn what you don’t" and my first vision was of the old concept of a people’s university, a concept I thought long since dead. These folks have revived it in a web context.

The metaphor of the site is simple, want to know something find a tutor; got something to teach then register as a tutor. The site develops a direct learner to student interface with cash changing hands with the learner paying the tutor and the site takes 10% off the top from the tutor. You can do the tutoring online, or face-to-face.

I found the pop-ups really annoying. The online learning interface is a chat screen and a white board (duh, netmeeting) and I am a little leery of the bandwidth issues especially since those staffing the booth indicated 56K was the min (and on a good day I get 26.6).

The poor folks in the booth had to put up with annoying talking fish next to them for four days, and they should get combat pay. One of the problems of the show in general is amplified sound from the vendors. "Fisheads, fisheads,,,eat em up yum.

Interface Software – LPT One

These folks actually have two little tools that are worth looking at. LPT One gives you a management tool for handling the chores of managing public print stations, and PC RESERVATION is a rather elegant tool for scheduling the workstations in your facility.

Once the net is in your place, you have to develop a printing policy. Be it free or a dime a page, whatcha gonna do about the kids printing 45 pages from the WWF site? To avoid the pushing and shoving match over who gets a box, most libraries implement a scheduling system.

Here’s the scoop on LPT One from their website:

Starting at less than $100 per workstation, small libraries will be able to control workstation printing by displaying the number of pages, print costs, and printer location. This versatile solution is easily upgraded with additional components as needs grow. The addition of a release station enables the circulation desk to control printing. This release station can share functionality with a circulation PC and provide the staff with a convenient means of managing patron printing from a central location. The exclusive cash register built into LPT:One provides a full-function software-based cash register to manage revenue from printing, collection of overdue book fines, and other cash transactions that occur at the circulation desk, even calculating change and printing receipts.

It includes client, station and reporting modules. What’s funky is not that nor more than a half-dozen booths down another outfit with a similar product. They wanted you to buy a server from them, pay $4.5K to say hello, and lacked many of the features of the

PC Reservation

Another hassle is monitoring who uses a workstation, when and for how long. This tool allows you to implement a login screen on the public pc’s and manage their use.

Here’s their scoop from their website:

A convenient cost-effective method of monitoring and controlling public PC use time and access - Highly scalable -- software and optional hardware fits every facility and all budgets -- starting at under $100 per PC for a Client Module - Schedules available PC resources for libraries and labs in a self-service or staff-managed mode - Operates as a software-only solution or integrated with our Silent Pager System - Vending devices can be integrated for authentication with student ID or patron library card - Reporting Module provides extensive statistical information and graphical displays - Manages sign-up for use of PC's, tracks time used, and expires student/patron sessions based upon administrator preferences.  Patrons are warned of time expiration with administrator-defined message and warning interval - Allows continued use of resources when there are no other patrons waiting - Advises waiting patrons of scheduled and probable wait time based upon statistical history - Works with any Windows 95/98/NT4/Win2000 station.  Does not require a file server - Integrates seamlessly with Interface's LPT:One Print Management System.  Licensing aggregates with LPT:One quantities to provide added cost savings -- LPT:One and PC Reservation share authentication and reporting systems.

netlibrary

The time spent with netlibrary was interesting, and they are on the edge of the ebook world. They spent a lot of advertising bucks, and I really enjoyed the coffee and danish they provided each morning in the show floor internet café. Living cheap is definitely living differently for your humble editor.

They have collected 15K plus titles, and make them available. Their pricing is retail with a discount (not stated) each time a title is downloaded. You can download it to a drive (but not an ebook or a palm or any other handheld, netlibrary claims the publishers won’t let them do it) and each download is timed so the cybercop cleans your drive.

There are some very elegant search features for finding content within a title, but duh, its hypertext anyway. The free reading room has 4K of titles (duh again, Project Gutenberg).

TOP

Brief (bikini?) Bits

Tool Kit for the Expert Web Searcher  LITA announced this toolkit at the conference. It’s a nice collection, but for reasons unknown leaves out Copernic, which is the Wired Librarian’s engine of choice. What is really needed is simple comparison table (like ZDnet does when you compare prices – thanks Squadron Quadrant Leader for that observation)

Terry Casey

I didn’t have time to hang out for Terry Casey’s ALTA program on "Library Trustees and Technology" Saturday AM , but he said he’d send me the notes and when he does ill post them.

 

ESRI

If you’re a GIS hack, or just a lover of maps, the folks at ESRI have the tools to manipulate GIS data. I didn’t stay long enough for price, but just watching over another greatly involved hack

LearnX

The print versions of these materials are more than familiar with public librarians faced with those trying to pass the postal (insert anything here) exam. At $14-$20K a pop I don’t think ill be taking a lot of them for s***s and giggles. The booth lady was gone, so I can’t tell ya if there is a discount for libraries.

AssociationCentral.com

Association Central ad

They get the award for best graphic at the show. However with 120K of associations, and their site listing 10K they got a long way to go to be an authoritative source. The rep said they were going to add 5K "real soon now" but their problem is they charge the association for the listing. So much for value added.

TOP

Joke of the Show

How low can you go? The Library Corporation, which used to be way up on my list of way cool vendors, used a juggler to pitch their wares. Combined with Taste of Chicago going on in Grant Park, it made for a perfect "bread and circuses" combo.

ALUG Reunion

ALUG reunion The coolest personal thing for me was the reunion tour for the Apple Library User’s Group (or ALUG for those in the know) on Sunday Evening at Pizzeria Uno, Chicago’s oldest pie place.

Monica Ertel, the former Apple Librarian attended as did Norman Kline, Ed & Linda Valuskas, Bill, Pat & Chris Vaccaro, and your humble editor. The highlight was going out on the street and calling the netmom herself, Jean Armour Polly.

TOP

Old Friends

The greatest satisfaction was running into old buds.Tom Schenk

Chuck FollettTo see Chuck Follett again was a real hoot, my old HS bud looks great and his new position at Follett doesn’t seem to be doing him any harm. And the guy filling his shoes, Tom Schenck looks like his new responsibilities fit him well. Dan Fuller has also moved up the Follett feeding chain, and he’s no longer within striking distance. The disk with his pic crashed so he’s got double luck.

Glen GrangerHow does he do it? When I ran into Glen Granger in the Highsmith booth, he looked better than he did five years ago. He indicated that plans were in the works to put their catalog online, and god-speed in that effort. I didn’t get the chance to see Duncan, but

 

First I ran into Betsy Thompson, then we ran into George Scheetz and it was like old days in Sioux City. We made plans to meet for dinner that fell through, and hence no mug shots. Betsy has been doing some very interesting stuff with measuring electronic service. It’s been fourteen years since I have seen either, and I don’t want that kind of time to elapse before the next encounter.

I hooked up with old compadre Bob Bocher from the Wisconsin Department of Education and caught up with his activities in developing technology skills in the cheese state.

TOP

How Stupid Is This?

Librarians tout themselves as the technology leaders, yet every year we pick a place, gather 20K and spend all of our time on busses moving from place to place.

Learning is moving from face to face, and I challenge ALA to look at the mayhem and develop an alternative plan, at least for part of the conference. Committee meetings need to be done online, and many of the content sessions need to become web-based instruction so that even those unable to afford to attend the conference could be part of the wisdom.

TOP

Even More Stupid

Mayor Daley at Opening SessionOn Friday afternoon, I felt very privileged to be part of the opening session. ALA gave a lifetime membership to the late Jeanne Hurley Simon, wife of former Senator Paul Simon (D-IL) and the crowd responded by giving him a standing ovation.

Just prior to this, the convention was addressed by His Honor, Richard M. Daley,Mayor Daley Mayor of the Great City of Chicago. I was in tears taking pictures near the podium because the boy is so much like his dad, Richard J.  Every man has his faults, and his dad had a few, but the second city was clean and functioned well during his tenure. Sure I protested in the streets (not that far from where McCormick stands) thirty-one years ago, but my beef wasn’t about the Boss, it was about the world we were trying to change.

Needless to say, Cognotes (the daily publication during the conference) waited until Sunday to run a pic, and then buried at the bottom of page 6 to boot. This is the guy who arranged the juice to build something like 28 new branches for CPL.

Librarians wonder why they struggle with the politicos. His Honor’s picture should have been top and center on the Saturday edition. Even without the buildings, just gracing us with his presence deserved more than a day late and a dollar short.

TOP

Notes on the Journey

There’s nothing more pleasing to your humble old editor than jumping in the truck and taking a six-hour tour, with or without Mary Ann or the Professor. I was looking forward to the return bout to my hometown (well kept secret, so it best be safe with thee) and perhaps the chance to loop some of the old courses in between the hectic pace of the show.

Cruising up I-65 through Batesville, IN hearing John Mellenkamp cranking out "Little Pink Houses" (and Ronnie want that as a campaign song?) … getting to Indy and hearing a great ad "Click Click Yum Yum " for indyfood.com … passing a truck with a concrete saw on the back and the logo "concrete barbers" … finally getting within range of WXRT FM 93.1 and hearing "TM on the FM in the PM" and waiting for Terri Hemmert in the morning … paying $22 a day to park my car …sitting in the shuttle bus line reading program announcements about distance learning and wondering why most of the sessions weren’t being done on the web …watching the jugglers sell automation systems.

TOP

Special Thanks To …

Deb Robertson and her staff in the ALA Press Office

Silver Platter for the neat little pull off markers to put in the program book. I wish I had about a thousand more for daily use.

Gale for providing the busses. Cuts the expenses tremendously for a guy without a job.

netlibrary for the free coffee and bagels, not to mention internet

 

An Index to the Online Issues

Wired Librarian's Newsletter Front Page

1983 - When there were four microcomputers at the ALA show

and hard drives were just a twinkle in my pappy's eye ...

May 1983 June 1983 June 1983 ALA Edition July 1983 August 1983 September 1983
November 1983 December 1983        

1984 - The industry awakens

January 1984 March 1984 April 1984 May 1984 June 1984 July 1984
August 1984 September 1984 October 1984 November 1984 December 1984

December 1984

The Mac Page

1985 - wow we've got hard drives !!! 

You've Got Rhythm who could ask for anything more?

January 1985 February 1985 March 1985 April 1985 May 1985 June 1985
July 1985 August 1985 September 1985 October 1985 August 200  

 

Page last modified Tuesday, November 08, 2005